The mascots of the Big 12 are ranked from worst to first.

10. TCU Horned Frog

While the Horned Frog, or more specifically, “SuperFrog,” is a unique mascot—being a real-life amphibian—it lacks the pizzazz seen in other mascots. SuperFrog, the costumed character, is a bit of a letdown visually. Despite the coolness of the horned frog itself, the mascot’s execution comes across as more quirky than intimidating. It’s a memorable mascot for sure, but its appeal is somewhat niche.

9. Kansas State Wildcats

The Kansas State Wildcat mascot, known as “Willie the Wildcat,” is a charming yet somewhat generic feline representation. While Willie has a friendly and approachable demeanor, the design isn’t particularly striking or imaginative. The costume is decent, but it doesn’t quite stand out in the crowded field of Big 12 mascots.

8. West Virginia Mountaineers

The West Virginia Mountaineers’ mascot, “The Mountaineer,” is a traditional character dressed in pioneer attire, complete with a coonskin cap and a rifle. While historically rich and representative of the rugged spirit of the region, the visual appeal of the Mountaineer can feel outdated. The character’s association with pioneer imagery is strong, but it lacks the dynamic presence seen in other Big 12 mascots.

7. Baylor Bears

“Brutus the Bear,” Baylor’s mascot, is a classic example of the bear archetype in college sports. The costume is well-designed and the bear’s friendly yet spirited demeanor suits the university’s identity. However, while Brutus is a solid mascot, it doesn’t offer the same level of excitement or originality as some of the higher-ranked mascots.

6. Oklahoma State Cowboys

Pistol Pete is the mascot for Oklahoma State, and he brings a certain Western flair to the table. With his cowboy hat, mustache, and six-shooter pistols, Pistol Pete exudes a lively and authentic cowboy vibe. The costume is impressive and the character is engaging, but it can sometimes be overshadowed by the flashier or more unique mascots of the Big 12.

5. University of Texas Longhorns

Bevo, the live longhorn steer, is an iconic symbol for the University of Texas. The sheer size and presence of Bevo make him a formidable mascot. He’s often seen on the sidelines, creating a sense of awe and grandeur. However, while Bevo’s impact is undeniable, the lack of a costumed counterpart or more interactive elements slightly diminishes his overall appeal.

4. Iowa State Cyclones

“Cy the Cardinal” represents Iowa State University and stands out for his vibrant, bird-like appearance. Cy is a high-energy mascot with a striking red and yellow costume that captures attention. His enthusiastic persona and engaging antics make him a fan favorite and give him a distinct place among the Big 12 mascots.

3. Kansas Jayhawks

The Kansas Jayhawks’ mascot, “Big Jay,” is a lively and colorful character that embodies the spirited and playful nature of the university. Big Jay’s flamboyant design, with bright colors and an animated presence, makes him one of the most recognizable mascots in the conference. His ability to energize the crowd and create a fun atmosphere places him high on the list.

2. Oklahoma Sooners

“Boomer and Sooner,” the pair of live ponies representing the University of Oklahoma, bring a unique and energetic element to the Sooners’ games. The pair’s tradition of riding onto the field before games is both visually impressive and historically significant. The spectacle of Boomer and Sooner in their bright crimson gear creates an electrifying atmosphere that’s hard to top.

1. Texas Tech Red Raiders

The top spot goes to “Raider Red” of Texas Tech. Raider Red is a dynamic, masked cowboy character with a strong, adventurous presence. His costume is highly detailed and his interactions with fans are spirited and entertaining. Raider Red stands out not just for his look but also for his ability to rally the crowd and embody the bold, fearless spirit of the Red Raiders.